EU Antitrust Watchdogs Quiz Daimler, Others On Failed Nokia Fee Talks

European Union antitrust regulators have asked Daimler, Continental and other car parts makers for details of failed mediation talks with Nokia in a patent licensing fee dispute.

Daimler, Continental, Bury Technologies, Valeo and Thales-owned Gemalto complained to the European Commission last year about the fees Finland’s Nokia was demanding for patents related to car communications.

The row highlights a wider battle between tech companies and the car sector over royalties for technologies key to navigation systems, vehicle communications and self-driving cars.

Europe wants to protect its technological sovereignty as Nokia and Ericsson are regarded as leading forces in the development of such technologies, while others say this should not be at the expense of other sectors such as autos.

Nokia initiated mediation with the companies, which sources said ended earlier this month without agreement. EU competition enforcers now want to know what happened, the people said.

Daimler, which owns the Mercedes-Benz luxury car brand, said the European Commission had sent a request for information.

The German company said it has a different legal opinion on how key patents should be licensed to the auto industry.

“Nokia so far refused to comprehensively and directly license our suppliers,” Daimler said.

“Fair and non-discriminatory access to these standards for all users of the essential patents for telecommunications standards is a key prerequisite for the development of new products and services for connected driving.”

The Commission declined comment, beyond saying that its investigation was ongoing.

Nokia said in an emailed statement that it has made fair licensing offers to automakers, tier-1 suppliers and through a collective licensing pool.

“Nokia has made several fair settlement offers … but unfortunately those offers have been rejected,” it added.

Continental, which is seeking a direct license for Nokia’s essential patents for 3G and 4G, said it would pursue its antitrust complaint against the telecoms equipment maker.

―New York Times